Kenneth
Clark: the poignant incongruence between the high gothic and
rennaissance extravagance in art and the greatness of the austerity in spritualism
that such art glorifies; a salient example being the 'great basilica' built
in honor of Saint Francis, which was 'decorated by all the chief Italian
painters of the thirteenth and fourteenth centuries, from Cimabue onwards',
this for the one who personified poverty : (Clark, like Panofsky, brings
up Chartres Cathedral to illustrate his point) : the glorification (and
deification) of the virgin: 'austere', 'modest', 'chaste', she is nonetheless
depicted in art as the object of human, earthly love : the origins of 'ideal or courtly love' : the conventional
conclusion that this phenomenon was imported from Persia during the crusades
along with the pointed arch of the gothic: '... I suppose
one must admit that the cult of the Virgin had something to do with it.
In this context it sounds rather blasphemous, but the fact remains that
one often hardly knows if a medieval love lyric is addressed to the poet's
mistress or to the Virgin Mary. The greatest of all writings about ideal
love, Dante's Vita Nuova, is a quasi religious work, and in the end it is
Beatrice who introduces Dante to Paradise.'